Review: A Year of Biblical Womanhood

In a new book, Rachel Held Evans shares her experience of trying to take the Bible’s commands for women literally for one year.

January 7, 2013 by Kristin Fryer

When I first heard about A Year of Biblical Womanhood, I was intrigued. The book chronicles Rachel Held Evans’ attempt to take all of the Bible’s instructions for women as literally as possible for a year, including not cutting her hair, calling her husband “master” and keeping silent in church.

Beyond the novelty factor, the experiment is a significant undertaking. Biblical womanhood is a hotly debated topic, attracting a wide range of interpretations and opinions. How would Evans address this? As it turns out, with intelligence, humour and a sincere desire to understand God’s will for women.

“There would be no picking and choosing,” writes Evans, who took all commands from Genesis to Revelation into account, while focusing on a particular virtue each month. It’s hard not to laugh when she describes trying to keep quiet while watching a football game during her month of gentleness or cook her first turkey dinner while focusing on domesticity.

But in chapters that focus on virtues such as obedience and submission, the tone is more serious as Evans discusses stories and passages in the Bible that are difficult for many modern women to read. For example, Old Testament law states that a woman who has been raped must marry her rapist (see Deuteronomy 22:28-29); in the New Testament, women are instructed to submit to their husbands “in everything,” as they submit to Christ (see Ephesians 5:24).

Evans doesn’t claim to have all the answers, but she does an admirable job of differentiating between culture-specific commands for women and timeless principles to live by. In doing so, she draws on a variety of sources as she explores the meaning of biblical womanhood, from theologians to ordinary people. One of the most fruitful relationships she develops over the course of the year is with an orthodox Jewish woman, Ahava, who offers insight into many Jewish laws and customs. For example, she explains that Proverbs 31 is not a to-do list for women, but a poem of praise that husbands sing to their wives every week at the Sabbath meal. “No matter what I do or don’t do, he praises me for blessing the family with my energy and creativity,” says Ahava. Everyone can be a “valorous woman” (see Proverbs 31:10) in their own way.

Adding to Evans’ personal reflections are profiles at the end of each chapter, which showcase the diversity of women in the Bible—from warriors to mothers, prostitutes to apostles. “What makes these women’s stories leap from the page is not the fact that they all conform to some kind of universal ideal,” Evans writes, “but that, regardless of the culture or context in which they found themselves, they lived their lives with valour. They lived their lives with faith.”

With so many heroines of the faith to learn from, perhaps it is no surprise that after 12 months of “biblical womanhood,” Evans reached a rather unconventional conclusion: that there is no such thing.

For more on biblical womanhood, read Salvationist‘s interview with Rachel Held Evans here.


  1. April McNeilly says:

    While I have not yet read Evans’ book, I did hear her interviewed on CBC radio by Jian Ghomeshi, and was intrigued (loved hearing about life during her menses) and a little concerned. My first thought was: “Great, another literal reading of Biblical passages which are so often used to hurt women and undermine their partnership with God.” Honestly, we have enough “scholarly” men doing this; we don’t need more women putting us in our place too! Having said that, I need to read her book to see what’s of value in it. Kristin Fryer says that Evans wrote the book with “a sincere desire to understand God’s will for women.” I would be interested to know if Kristin feels that Evans has any serious light to shed on this hotly debated issue… or do the waters continue to be muddied. Guess I’ll read the book!

  2. I also heard her on the radio and was intrigued. Then an officer colleague posted that it was a good read so I downloaded her book and started reading. What a delightful read! She’s not advocating a biblical interpretation – she’s being critical of a too strict interpretation that binds women forever in a 1st century construct. She has a wonderful style of writing, she’s funny and she’s done her homework. I agree with her conclusion.

Speak Your Mind


Building a Future

Building a Future

Trade Start helps at-risk youth find a better path.

The Unlikely Disciples

The Unlikely Disciples

In the midst of fear, weakness and doubt came the news that led to great faith.

Opinion & Critical Thought

House of Prayer

House of Prayer

Should churches make room for other religions?

Not by Sight

Not by Sight

Learning to encounter God in the dark.

Territorial News

2015 Executive Appointments Announced

These Salvation Army appointments within the Canada and Bermuda Territory are effective June 26, August 28 and September 1, 2015.

Canadian Council of Churches Expresses Concern Over ISIS

Church leaders write to Prime Minister Stephen Harper with reservations concerning Canada’s military mission.

International News

Salvation Army Leaders at Memorial for Victims of Germanwings Air Disaster

Army expresses condolences, offers support.

General Cox Visits the Middle East

General Cox Visits the Middle East

Meeting shows the international nature of The Salvation Army.

Faith & Friends

Surviving the Den

Surviving the Den

As a Dragons’ Den graduate and successful entrepreneur, Desmond Choi fuses passion for business with his faith.

Jacob’s Journey

Jacob’s Journey

With the love of his family, the support of his church and the dedication of medical specialists, a young boy battled a killer heart condition.