Flying High: Billy Graham (far left), accompanied by Charles Templeton (far right) prepare to leave Chicago’s Municipal Airport in 1946 en route for a crusade in Europe (Photo: Courtesy of Billy Graham Center Archives)Flying High: Billy Graham (far left), accompanied by Charles Templeton (far right) prepare to leave Chicago’s Municipal Airport in 1946 en route for a crusade in Europe (Photo: Courtesy of Billy Graham Center Archives)

The Pastor and the Agnostic

We could not have been less alike, yet we made a difference in each other's lives.

October 17, 2013 by Beverly Ivany


Charles Templeton. While he is little-known now, there was a time not too long ago when the evangelist was a household name in Canada, a powerful preacher on a par with his friend Billy Graham. In the late 1940s and ’50s, his crusades attracted tens of thousands of people across Canada and the United States, and his rallies in places such as Maple Leaf Gardens in Toronto, Chicago’s Soldier Field and the Rose Bowl in California were phenomenally successful. My pastor father once contacted him to speak at our Salvation Army church. Hundreds packed the church that evening, soaking up his every word. In the course of two decades, thousands became Christians because of him.

Then one day, he renounced his faith, explaining that he’d realized everything he’d preached for more than two decades was a lie. It was a shocking announcement, especially for those who had come to faith through his ministry.

Templeton eventually became a well-known journalist and broadcaster, executive managing editor of the Toronto Star, and then editor-in-chief of Maclean’s. As well, he authored 12 books in 51 editions and 11 languages.

First Contact
In the late 1990s, a friend lent me Templeton’s Farewell to God, which explained why he had rejected the Christian faith. Now a Salvation Army pastor myself, I was greatly disturbed by it. That this man could write a book renouncing God in such a public and demeaning way—and make lots of money from it—troubled me deeply, and I decided to try and contact him.

Templeton lived in Toronto, so he was easy to look up in the telephone directory. He was surprised by my call but was more than willing to chat as he greatly respected The Salvation Army. Interestingly, he thought I was calling because I was wavering in my faith now that I had read his book, and was intrigued when I replied that his book actually strengthened my belief in God, because I knew the spiritual life was all about faith.

In the course of the conversation, he told me that every Good Friday, he would go to his study to meditate upon Jesus—His goodness, His selflessness, His humanity—for three hours. How many Christians meditate upon Christ for three hours? I asked myself. I knew then that there was still something there—deep down.

Before that first conversation was over, he asked me to send him some of my writing. I cautioned him that it was all Christian-based. He replied that it didn’t matter. He wanted to see what I was writing about and promised to call me back with his “comments.”

charles-templeton-beverly-ivany

Friends Forever: On her last visit, Charles Templeton gave Major Beverly Ivany a signed copy of Farewell to God. “It is a book with which I profoundly disagree, and yet I still treasure it”

Treasured Copy
This was the beginning of a five-year friendship conducted primarily over the phone. Every couple of months or so, he would call out of the blue. They were fascinating conversations. We’d update one another on our families and talk about the events of the day, but we always ended up talking about matters of faith.

Once, he asked me if I was “brainwashing” my four teenaged children.

“No,” I replied. “Their dad and I try to influence them by example.”

“Do you think they’ll end up being Christians like you?” he pressed.

“I don’t know but I pray that they will be,” I replied. “In the end, they have a choice.”

After a few years, Templeton became sick and had to be placed in an assisted-living facility. By then, I was living in Montreal. His wife phoned and asked that if I was ever in Toronto, would I go and see him. I did. It was then that he gave me my own autographed copy of Farewell to God. It is a book with which I profoundly disagree, and yet I still treasure it.

Found Faith
One night that June, I was watching the nightly news when I saw a report that Charles Templeton had died. The next morning, his wife, Madeleine, called and asked me to attend his wake.

When I arrived to pay my respects in my Salvation Army uniform, a journalist colleague of his confronted me with a gruff, “What’s the Sally Ann doing here?”

Before I could stammer a reply, his wife interjected with, “You leave her be. She was a friend of Charles and he would have wanted her to be here.”

With that, the man retreated and left us alone. After I expressed my sympathies, she thanked me for coming, and told me about his last words: “Madeleine, do you see them? Do you hear them? The angels! They’re calling my name! I’m going home!”

“What do you make of that, Bev?” she asked me.

“I really believed he finally made peace, in his own very private way, with God—and that he was going home to be with Jesus,” I replied. I told her that Charles was going to be one of the first people I would look for when I got to Heaven.

Templeton and I could not have been more different in life, yet we each had an influence on the other. I greatly respected his intellect and breadth of knowledge, and I’ve tried to become a better writer thanks to his example. I pray I’ve succeeded. And I’d like to think that I helped him—in my own small way—find some of the faith he thought he’d abandoned forever.

 

beverly-ivanyWriter In Residence: “Charles Templeton will be one of the first people I look for when I get to Heaven,” says Salvation Army Major Beverly Ivany, who currently is the author of the Words of Life series of daily devotionals

Comments

  1. Thank you for sharing this. I am blessed by your writings (Words of Life) and especially so by
    having read this.

    God bless.
    Lou

  2. This article insprire me and streghten my faith. I am blest. It gives an insight that we should not be prejudice in any person around us. We need to make the gospel of Christ as a living gospel in our daily life. Demonstrated the Christ that we have that make influence to the lives of others. It is not our rule to change people but we can be the agent of their change by the power and the working of the Holy Spirit.

    God will continue to bless your ministry.

  3. Keith Pond says:

    Thanks Bev for this article. I read Lee Strobel’s Case for Christ some years ago. For his research , Templeton was interviewed. He said that he missed Jesus. This made me so sad as I read the passage.

  4. God bless you, Major, for this article. I had heard so much about Charles Templeton and about his dramatic about-turn against Christ. It then stunned me to read about his hearing the angels calling him home. What a powerful testament to Christ’s grace, mercy and love for all of us…thank you!

  5. Thanks for this post.it has strengthened my faith in Jesus.

  6. After reading the interview that Lee Strobel had with Mr Templeton I had always wondered if he had regained his faith in Jesus as Lord. Now I have my answer.
    I have been doing a bible study on apostasy and the different views that people hold about it. Through these studies I have come to the conclusion that we can turn away from God but He will not turn away from us. Charles Templeton is a case in point.

    Thankyou for this article.

  7. Edna Way says:

    As a teenager, I attended Charles Templeton’s meetings at the Wesley United Church in St. John’s, . Newfoundland. Every night the church was filled with people. I still remember some of his sermons. His wife at that time was a trained singer and they both sang duets together. I will never forget one they sang,” O Love That Wilt Not Let Me Go” I was hurt when I learned that he had turned his back on God. However, I’m more than happy to learn that he did come back to the God he so faithfully preached about.

  8. Roy Isherwood says:

    re. Beverly Ivany’s article on Charles Templeton: Why are you printing an article and comments from 2013? It is interesting and I remember reading it when it first came out. Are you short of material? There must be something more current that you could publish.

    Roy,
    The article was not republished. This comment appears in the “recent comments” because the reader searched our archive. We have an extensive list of articles that readers can access. Comments are not turned off since some may choose to continue the discussion, even years later. God bless you.
    Geoff Moulton
    Editor-in-Chief

  9. Glen Bailey says:

    Interesting article thanks for sharing. I’m a big fan of Christopher Hitchens who referenced Templeton as a role model. Like you I have to respect both of these men for their thoughtfulness though their theological musings are often hurtful to believers. There’s something very compelling about them and I agree that it only strengthens one’s faith to ponder their writings.

Speak Your Mind

*

An Atheist’s Prayer

An Atheist’s Prayer

I didn’t believe in God. So why was I so angry with him?

In Harm’s Way

In Harm’s Way

My daughter and I healed our self-inflicted scars together.

Opinion & Critical Thought

The Red Dress

The Red Dress

We were promised a national inquiry into the missing and murdered Indigenous women. What’s taking so long?

The Key to Forgiveness

The Key to Forgiveness

How my imperfections as a parent showed me the depth of grace.

Territorial News

Booth University College Welcomes 2017 Graduates

Booth University College Welcomes 2017 Graduates

Chief of the Staff encourages graduates to “choose well” as they go forth into the world.

Cooler Brings Healthy Choices to French Creek

Cooler Brings Healthy Choices to French Creek

Salvation Army food bank launches food reclamation project.

International News

General Responds to Manchester Attack, Calling Salvationists to Share Peace

General Responds to Manchester Attack, Calling Salvationists to Share Peace

Salvation Army assists more than 400 people in the hours immediately following the attack.

Salvation Army Joins Churches Worldwide to Pray for End to Famine

As millions face starvation, General calls on Salvationists to take action.

Faith & Friends

Fair Trade in an Unfair World

Fair Trade in an Unfair World

We can make a difference with every thoughtful purchase we make.

Movie Review: King Arthur: Legend of the Sword

Movie Review: King Arthur: Legend of the Sword

In King Arthur: Legend of the Sword, a streetwise gang leader confronts the person he is meant to be.