If you were to sit in the pew of a Salvation Army corps one Sunday and a Presbyterian church the next, you might not notice many significant differences on the surface. Same Lord’s Prayer. Same sort of hymns, although the Salvation Army congregation will likely clap more. Same basic conviction that people need saving and God is the one who does it.

But if you asked the people filing out after the service why they believe, you’ll eventually bump into a 500-year-old argument that neither congregation invented and neither has fully let go. At its heart is a single question: does God choose who will be saved, or does God make salvation possible for everyone and leave the choosing to us?

Two distinct theological traditions, Calvinism and Arminianism (the latter usually going by “Wesleyan” in Salvation Army circles), answer that question in opposite directions, and nearly everything else—how grace works, whether it can be refused, whether it can be lost—follows from there. 

THE ROOTS OF A THEOLOGICAL DEBATE

It’s worth knowing where the argument comes from, because the Arminian half of the debate is older and less familiar than people might think. Jacobus Arminius was a Dutch theologian working around 1600, a full 150 years before the English evangelist and priest John Wesley was even born. Arminius pushed back hard against the strict Calvinism of his day, particularly the concept of “election,” which teaches that God chooses who will be saved without any regard to the person’s own response.

After Arminius died in 1609, his followers gathered his objections into a document called the Five Articles of Remonstrance. It laid out five propositions: 1) that election is conditional upon faith in Christ, and that God elects those he knows will have faith in him; 2) that Christ died for all people rather than only the elect; 3) that people cannot believe without the help of grace; 4) that this grace can, nonetheless, be resisted; and 5) that whether a believer could fall away from grace was, at that point, still an open question that the Remonstrants weren’t ready to settle.

The Dutch Reformed establishment did not take this well. In 1618, a national synod convened at Dort to respond, formally condemned the Remonstrants and issued five canons of its own, doctrines that came to be known by the acronym TULIP: total depravity, unconditional election, limited atonement, irresistible grace and perseverance of the saints.

Read side by side, the two documents are practically a point-by-point rebuttal of each other. Where the Remonstrance says election depends on foreseen faith, Dort says election is unconditional. Where the Remonstrance says Christ died for everyone, Dort says the atonement is limited to the elect. Where the Remonstrance leaves resistible, losable grace on the table, Dort insists grace is irresistible and the saints will always persevere. TULIP is not just a summary of Calvinism, in other words. It is a direct answer to the Arminians, drafted specifically to shut their position down. 

THE PORCH LIGHT OF GRACE

It didn’t work, at least not permanently. In the 1700s, John Wesley read Arminius’ Remonstrance, found the argument persuasive and built his own theology—and eventually the Methodist denomination—largely on Arminian foundations, adding his own distinctive emphases along the way. So, when people use “Arminian” and “Wesleyan” almost interchangeably, that’s not quite right, but it’s close enough to be useful. Wesley is Arminianism’s most famous export, not its source.

The Salvation Army grew directly out of Methodism, so it inherited and was formed by this Wesleyan-Arminian DNA, and it shows up in what the people sitting in those pews believe.

DOES GOD CHOOSE WHO WILL BE SAVED, OR DOES GOD MAKE SALVATION POSSIBLE FOR EVERYONE AND LEAVE THE CHOOSING TO US?

Take the question of election first, since it’s where the two systems split hardest. Calvinism’s answer is that God chooses. Before the world even existed, God elected certain people for salvation, and that election isn’t based on anything about the person, foreseen faith or otherwise. When grace shows up for the elect, it’s a done deal.

The Wesleyan-Arminian answer is a fundamentally different understanding. Grace is offered to everybody, not a chosen few. And it shows up earlier than most people realize. Wesley called it “prevenient grace,” grace that goes ahead of a person before they’ve done a thing to earn or even look for it. Picture it less like a formal invitation and more like a porch light somebody left on for you. It won’t bring you through the door. But it means nobody’s stumbling around in total darkness, either. By the time someone in the pew feels that first tug toward faith, grace already beat them to it. 

THE WORK OF HOLINESS

This is also where the two camps split hardest on free will, and it’s really the same question as the election debate, just asked from the other direction: is a person’s yes to God a real choice, or simply the unfolding of a decision God already made? Calvinists hold that once grace grabs hold of the elect, it can’t be refused and can’t be lost. Perseverance of the saints means: once you’re in, you’re in for good.

The Wesleyan-Arminian crowd, the Army included, holds something tougher and, honestly, more demanding. Grace can be turned down. Faith is a real, live and lived response, not a foregone conclusion. And because it’s an actual relationship rather than a permanent status, it can be walked away from, too. Somebody can fall from grace. That last bit tends to rattle people who grew up Reformed or from a Calvinist background. It’s worth saying that it’s not meant as a scare tactic, rather as a statement about what faith is.

If salvation is a status you get once and can never lose, it doesn’t ask much of you afterward. If it’s a relationship you live out, it asks what every real relationship asks: you show up and you keep showing up.

Salvationists call that ongoing work “holiness,” and we’ve built a whole doctrine around it, entire sanctification, which is the idea that grace isn’t just about getting forgiven but about getting changed, a “second work” that keeps refining a person well past the day they first believed. 

OUT THE DOOR AND INTO THE STREET

And here’s the part that explains what people notice about the Army as an organization. Wesley talked about “social holiness,” the idea that holiness that never leaves your own head isn’t holiness at all. Holiness must be lived out. If grace is for everybody, and if the whole point of getting it is ongoing change rather than a one-time transaction, the next logical move is out the door and into the street. The shelters, the Christmas kettles, the addiction recovery programs: these aren’t charity work bolted onto a private belief system. They’re what the congregation’s theology looks like once it’s lived out, showing the love of Christ to the world.

None of this settles an argument that’s outlasted several empires, a Dutch synod and a fair number of denominational splits since. Calvinism and Arminianism are both serious, coherent attempts to answer a genuinely hard question.

But next time we stand on a kettle or serve in the local corps’ food bank, it’s worth knowing that those acts of service aren’t incidental to Salvation Army theology. It is the theology, worn on the outside.

DR. MICHAEL W. BOYCEis the director, academics, at the College for Officer Training and Leadership Development.

Illustration: OMIA/stock.Adobe.com; Oleksandr Kovalov/iStock via Getty Images Plus

This story is from:

Leave a Comment